Wojciech Bońkowski
Master of Wine

Tea and chocolate

An exercise matching tea and chocolate. Can this work at all? Isn’t chocolate too powerful to have with tea? I try some artisanal chocolate pralines with green, oolong, black and puer tea.

Tea bonanza

42 teas in one day

By pure coincidence (well, a polite way to thank Polish Mail for holding packages for two weeks for ‘customs inspection’) I’ve received no less than four shipments of tea today. Now this is real embarras de richesse! My Japanese 2009s are here (tins on the photo above are from Marukyu-Koyamaen and there’s another box from O-Cha; I must praise the latter’s service as they’ve replaced an order that went missing, free of charge on EMS) and I’ll dedicate a series of future posts of various shinchas and gyokuros from these two vendors.

New season teas also include a dozen Darjeelings from Lochan; these are actually free samples that are being sent out on a promotional scheme where you only need to pay for (very efficient) shipping. I really draw your attention to this offer (currently available for both first and second flushes) as it allows for very interesting comparison between various single estates teas including the famous ones of Margaret’s Hope, Castleton, Jungpana etc. More on these teas on this blog soon.

By contrast I’ve also ordered a box of various aged puer samples from Nadacha (and some excitingly affordably yixing clay jars):


I’ve started the exploration with a black tea from Nada:

The 2009 Fengqing Wai Shi Li is a high-grade spring flush from the Fengqing Tea Factory (and more specifically their Dianhong brand) who are classic producer of both black tea and (more recently) puer. It’s fairly inexpensive at £6 / 100g, and I also very much like Nada’s wabi-sabi packaging:


Brewed in: gaiwan
Dosage: 3g/140ml
Dry leaf: Rather small leaves with a degree of golden tips but overall colour is darkish. Aroma is typically Yunnan and very hongcha: earthy, herby, rather unfruity, not terribly complex or deep; perhaps a bit of smokiness. No increase in intensity as the leaf is warmed.

Tasting notes:
45s: The profile of this brew is best described as ‘traditional’. It has a subdued aroma dominated by earth and smoke, with no fruit frills. The nose might be unremarkable but the flavoury is very good, with medium body and a less oblivious oxidation than I expected from the nose. Hardly a lot of complexity or poise but this is good for the price. I might have been just lucky with the brewing parameters as this is showing a perfect balance of tannins and body. Really quite traditional: rather solid and oxidised, less fruity than many modern examples of black Yunnan but more consistent and solid.

Brewing #1 (45 seconds).
2m: Lighter than brewing #1 even with the prolonged time, exposing a somewhat naked finish but the profile is more or less maintained. I won’t brew it a third time though.

Overall this is satisfying tea for the price. Another good buy from Nada! This also makes me curious about the other 2009 Fengqing black that he’s offering.

2008 Haoya Keemun ‘Nonpareil’

Remembrance of tastes past
As for probably 99% of Europeans, my first taste of tea was black. In the late 1980s, nobody heard of green tea, and ‘oolong’ was a mediocre low-bracket disaster you better steered clear of. In the late 1980s in Poland, there were no teabags (at least I don’t remember them); tea was purchased in small cardboard boxes or loose brown paper bags. Generic geographical names were used – Assam, Ceylon, Madras – with little guarantee of authenticity but a broad consistency of taste: Assam was a very deeply coloured, heftily tannic brew while Georgian tea (very popular in Eastern Block countries) was of the lighter, fruitier, spicier kind. There was not tea connoisseurship; tea was a staple, and left an indelible aromatic imprint on my childhood memories of afternoon meetings of adults.

With the fall of Communism here in 1989, tea became a commodity governed by market forces. Standards fell as teabags came into fashion. There was so little interest in the watery brew they generated that I gave up tea altogether. It was only in 1996 or 1997 that I came back. By then, a couple of specialist tea merchants were operating in Warsaw. They had perhaps 75 varieties of loose leaf on offer. Today, I wouldn’t give a penny for that no-name TGFOP Assam sitting next to a strawberry-scented Gunpowder, but at the time it was a massive change.

‘Black’ (now sometimes defined as ‘red’ following the Chinese nomenclature) tea constituted 75% of my early tea consumption, and I had two favourites: Yunnan and Keemun. The former’s red-fruity, crisp taste on sunny days and the latter’s malty depths on rainy ones.

So it was a kind of sentimental journey to order the 2008 Haoya ‘A’ Keemun ‘Nonpareil’ from Dragon Tea House. This pricy tea ($24 / 100g) is the highest grade of black offered by this merchant (Haoya being a top grade of Keemun and A the highest quality of Haoya). Brewed in: gaiwan
Dosage: 3.5g / 150ml
Dry leaf: Very small – this is clearly a top grade. A uniform dark brown/black with a minor amount of golden tips. (Later a proportion of twig bits will be revealed in the wet leaf). Dry leaf aroma is that unmistakeable Keemun malty smoke spice. Tasting notes:
I experimented with brewing times during several sessions, going from 15s to 60–90s for the first brewings, and continuing pretty much at will. (Patience of this tea is average but three reasonable infusions can be obtained, though #1 is always best). Dark red-brown, this is not a particularly deep colour for black tea. Nose is quite distinctive and immediately brings memories of those inexpensive blended Keemun teas I was drinking as a student: little fruit, lots of maltiness and smoke, some heavier earthy notes. On the palate this again shows that Keemun’s comfortable malty oxidation and few ‘primary’ fruit notes, to use a vinous term. Not very tannic even when brewings are lengthy; finish is firm not drying. If this was a wine, it would be a Madiran or young Cahors with its chewy tannins and earthy fruit. Overall this is a good (perhaps very good) example of its appellation, but not a ‘wow’ tea and perhaps I expected more at this price.